Thursday, April 1, 2010

Formation of an Argument: Theist

Theist:
• Now a theist would argue the point of the teleological argument
Teleological argument:
1) Every design had a designer
2) The universe is a highly complex design
3) Therefore, the universe had a designer

1) William Paley stated that every watch requires a watchmaker; you can’t just walk along in the woods and find a diamond-studded Rolex and assume that some random combination of natural forces caused that watch to be. That’s unreasonable.
2) The universe is specifically tweaked to enable life on earth; earth is a tiny oasis in a vast and hostile universe, how can that be? Earth is completely interdependent and extremely fine-tuned…the “Anthropic Principle”
• There are 122 defined constants that allow earth to be
• Here are a few:
1) Oxygen level in the atmosphere of earth is exactly 21% if it were greater fires would occur spontaneously, if it were less, we would suffocate
2) The transparency of our atmosphere allows enough solar radiation to reach the earth’s surface, if it were more transparent we would receive too much radiation
3) The moon/earth gravitational interaction is so exact that it if it were less the orbital changes would cause our climate would become instable, if it were greater, tidal effects on the ocean, atmosphere and rotational period would cause life to be impossible
4) The amount of carbon dioxide in our atmosphere is another factor. It is adjusted just right to allow us to release it through respiration. If there were greater amounts of carbon dioxide a runaway greenhouse effect would take place, and we’d all burn up. If it were less, plants would not be able intake it through photosynthesis and release oxygen for us
5) The gravitational force is so specific that if it was altered 0.00000000000000000000000000000000000001 (10-37) percent our sun wouldn’t exist.
6) If the centrifugal forces of planetary movements did not precisely balance that gravitational forces, nothing could be held in orbit around the sun
7) If the universe had expanded at a rate one millionth more slowly than it did (during the Big Bang), expansion would have stopped, and the universe would of collapsed on itself before any stars had formed. If it had expanded faster, then no galaxies would have formed.
8) Any of the laws of physics can be described as a function of the velocity of light. Even a slight variation in the speed of like would alter the other constants and prelude the possibility of life on earth
9) If water vapor levels in the atmosphere were greater than they are now, a runaway greenhouse effect would cause temperatures to rise too high for human life; if they were less, an insufficient greenhouse effect would make the earth too cold to support human life.
10) If Jupiter where not in its current orbit, the earth would be bombarded with space material. Jupiter’s gravitational field acts as comic vacuum cleaner, attracting asteroids and comets that might otherwise strike earth.
11) If the thickness of earth’s crust were greater, too much oxygen would be transferred to the crust to support life. If it were thinner, volcanic and tectonic activity would make life impossible.
12) If the rotation of earth took longer than 24 hours, temperature differences would be too great between night and day. If the rotation period were shorter, atmospheric wind velocities would be too great.
13) The 23- degree axial tilt of the earth is just right. IF the tilt were altered slightly, surface temperatures would be too extreme on earth.
14) If the atmospheric discharge (lightning) rater were greater, there would be too much fire destruction; if it were less, there would be too little nitrogen fixing in the soil.
15) If there were more seismic activity (earthquakes), much more life would be lost; if there was less, nutrients on the ocean floors and in river runoff would not be cycled back into the continents through tectonic uplift.
• Hugh Ross (astrophysicist) calculated the probability that all these constants could exist in another planet
-assume there are 1022 planets in the universe and there are only 1070 atoms in the entire universe. According to Ross, there is a one in 10138 chance (that’s practically zero) that any planet could have the life supporting conditions we have, unless there is an intelligent Designer behind it.

Thursday, March 18, 2010

Formation of an Argument:Atheist

There are multiple debates regarding the cause of our universe. In my research I focused specifically on an atheist view, believing that the Big Bang theory is true, but that it was caused by natural forces. The opposing argument being, the theist view that the Big Bang also occurred, but it was caused by an intelligent Designer.

There are so many different questions, each leading to a new question, which made it hard to narrow my research. I wanted to begin with the atheist side of the argument, since that’s what I knew least about. It was rather difficult to find hard evidence, such as a theory or law, proving that we are only here due to natural forces. From what I knew, that meant that the universe just happened at random chances. That around 13.7 billion years ago, there was the universe, in one single point. This point, being smaller the size of a pinhead; a point where all space, time, and matter were in one. Then an explosion caused this point to expand. This was the foundation of the universe, but it is unknown what was before the Big Bang. And that is where the controversy begins, what caused that explosion?

• The truth is, we don’t know. We don’t know what caused the explosion that caused our expanding universe.
• In some cases atheists use a multiple universe theory
-Dr. Peter Atkins in his book, The Creation Revisited wrote, “Now, we go back in time beyond the moment of creation to where there was no time, and to where there was no space.” He goes on to say that in the time before time he imagines a “swirling dust of mathematical points which recombine again and again and again and finally come by trial and error to form our space time universe.”
-more specifically the multiple universe theory states that there are actually an infinite number of universes in existence, and by chance our universe exploded with the right conditions to create an earth that supports human life
-yet I could not find any evidence supporting this theory
-Times Magazine wrote an article on scientists finding other galaxies within our universe that were created in the infancy of the universe. This challenges the theory of cold, dark matter taking billion of years to form galaxies.
- even science is constantly observing and renewing theories as technology enhances

• Another argument I found was that since there was no time before the big bang, there was no time for anything to be.
-St. Augustine of Hippo stated that the world was made “not in time, but simultaneously with time.”
-therefore, why is it weird that our universe just randomly burst into being. With the support of quantum physics it is normal for matter such as atoms and molecules to spontaneously come into and out of existence.

Labor Movements


Previously, I had a US History episode, which was very random for me. I'm not much of a social studies person, but again I had a bit of an episode resulting in the research of unions from the beginning of the 1900's to today. I guess what got me started was my project I had to do for my history class, but what I found was super interesting so I decided to share some of it with you.

From the beginning of WWI and up until today, laborers across America have fought for their rights. In 1914 the National War Labor Board was created, and headed by William Howard Taft. The board gained rights with an increase in wages and a strict eight hour day. With this the membership in unions increased. In the year of 1919, laborers were not happy with their wages; over 4 million workers went on strike. The discontent of workers continued into the Great Depression, where jobs became scarce. Various administrations and acts were created by congress to produce more jobs and protect workers rights. An example being the Wagner Act of 1935 which gave workers rights to unionize and bargain collectively. In the 1930s union membership was at a point of about 3 million members, but by the 1940s it increased to over 10 million members. The American Federation of Labor was a popular union, only open to white, skilled male workers. The federation was a less radical group, compared to others, with a more authoritative presence. In 1938 the first “code of conduct” for business was created: the Fair Labor Standards Act. This made a minimum wage of 40 cents an hour, a maximum work week of forty hours and restrictions for child labor under the age of 16. WWII was a period of no strikes; the Taft-Hartley Labor Act limited powers of unions and the circumstanced in which they could strike. In the 1950s union gains, such as with GM occurred and by the 1960s 1/3 of Americans were members of a union. With the AFL and CIO merging, big unions meant more power, with many blue-collar workers who had middle class incomes. At the time, unions seemed good, but from the 1970s-1980s the government created a series of antiunion policies. In 1970, 180,000 postal workers stuck, later on President Reagan began harsh on union members. In 1990 only 14 percent of the population belonged to the union. Today, there are 7 major unions representing 6 million workers.

Job Shadowing Day 1

This week, I had an amazing opportunity to job shadow at my equestrian vet clinic. The place is called River Basin and it is run by Dr. Kirk Heistercamp and Dr. Christine Wilkins. I've been trying to get an internship or part time job with River Basin since last summer, but I feel like I was being a bother with all my calls. They just didn't have a position open. So, early this year, I started a head of the game and called Dr. Christine asking for a summer job or even a job shadow when I'm not busy with school. Still, they had no openings for a part time job. I knew that this experience would be essential to my future education in equine medicine, so I didn't give up. We had a half day of school on a Monday and I decided that I needed to get some grain and anti fungus for Sly's ears. I had hoped to talk to Dr. Chris about a job of some sort, but she seemed busy with a client that day. Later on, though, my riding instructor, Robin Sumner, went in t buy some grain. When she arrived at the clinic, Dr. Chris and Dr. Kirk had finished the x-rays and were just chatting, so Robin brought up how I wanted a position with them. Apparently she put in a really good word for me. I called Dr. Chris the next week and practically begged for an opportunity of some sort, and I got one.


So, this week I was able to go in on Tuesday: day one.


Right away I got to watch the vets prepare for a castration surgery. Anything can happen once you have a horse in surgery, so they had to prepare for everything. If something went wrong, they had to be ready. I was able to help here and there with little things such as holding buckets, handing clamps, supporting the horse as the anesthesia set in ect. The surgery was fascinating. They had to hoist the young colt onto the table, and began. It was fairly simple. The vet doing most of the work, with an assistant by him side. After everything was complete, they took him off the table, and let him lay on the ground until the anesthesia wore off.

Day 1 was complete. Though, the next day was quite the event as well.

Thursday, March 11, 2010

More About the Big Bang

I found this video very interesting and useful to my research about the Big Bang and such, so take a look:)



Tuesday, March 9, 2010

Nutrition


There are six main sources of nutrition for the horse. These are rather simple in that they include: water, carbohydrates, proteins, fatty acids/lipids, vitamins, and minerals. Water is obviously most important, since horses drink up to 12 gallons of water a day. You want to be sure that you keep fresh, and clean water available at ALL TIMES. Carbohydrates are the main source of energy in a horse’s diet. They obtain these from hay, grains, and grasses. These are made up of plant starches in which carbon, hydrogen and oxygen are main elements. As a horse digests carbohydrates he breaks them up into starches and sugars which are used for energy, and cellulose which is the main source of fiber.

Side Fact: When a horse is fed normal amounts of grain, but contained in a stall for several days, then sporadically worked really hard, Azoturia is a serious resulting problem. Azoturia is more commonly known as “tying up”. This is when the horse Begins to show signs of distress, such as stiffness and a short stride in the hind legs. They will immediately begin to have hard, tense, quivering muscles of the hind leg. Other symptoms include dark urine, high temperature, sweating, restlessness and anxious attitude. He will resist movement. This is very serious, and you want to call your vet ASAP!

Monday, March 8, 2010

My Project

Remember me writing about a research topic? Well I chose to write about the beginning of the universe and since then I have done a ton of research and presented that to the class. I thought it went really well, but now I’m continuing my research to find strong evidence for my essay. I already know that I want to argue the existence for God through the beginning of the universe. The reason being, that it’s a controversial topic, but it’s the most significant thing God has ever done, or as Christians, and myself say, it’s His biggest miracle. If you can believe that a loving merciful God created life as we know it, it’s easy to believe everything else the Bible says. For an example; if God created the water, don’t you think His son Jesus would be able to walk on it? You see, once you believe God created life, its easy to understand that he can easily manipulate it.

Now the problem is, I’ve got to prove God exists. Like my teacher said, it’s hard to argue an improvable point. I cannot completely prove God exists, but as juniors in high school, we can’t technically prove anything else we try to argue either. The thing is when I write this paper, I don’t want my argument to go around in circles. I say one thing; an atheist responds with another thing, I defend myself with another point, and so on. It’d be a never ending essay if I did that! Yet, right now, that’s how the debate continues. Someone says on thing, and the opposing argument says another and the sides keep arguing, never coming to a final conclusion.

So, my goal of this essay will simply prove that God was the cause of the big bang to a point of unreasonable doubt. Meaning, that I make the most logical argument by using the strongest evidence and refute any questions that come up.

Wednesday, February 10, 2010

Wow Theres More...

I seem to be finding a TON on the history of child labor. WOW! I can't believe some of this stuff!

Even though new ideas were being developed about the use of children for labor, conditions were still very bad. Normally the environment was cramped and hazardous. Coal mines were extremely dangerous; the breaker boys would sit on a wooden board watching coal and slate flow by through the coal chutes, once in a while, a boy would slip into the coal chute and be smothered to death. The air was thick with dust, and the coal would cut their fingers. In the mines themselves, there was always a fear of cave-ins or explosions. These conditions were completely dark, since they were about five hundred feet below the surface.

In cotton mills such as Cornell Mill in Fall River, Massachusetts, children could be employed as spinners, doffers and sweepers. Girls were usually spinners; walking up and down the aisles brushing lint off the machines, and watching for breaks in the thread that had to be mended quickly. Usually a spinner was on her feet eleven to twelve hours a day, six days a week.

Sweatshops seem much worse, compared to a mill. Here girls and women would do various tasks such as making jewelry, sewing buttons, setting stones, sewing pieces or whole parts of clothing and so on. These tasks were either accomplished at home, with multiple other women, or in a small business located usually in a rundown building. Both places were fire hazards since they were not ventilated very well, and it either was too hot or too cold. Often places were infested with rats and poisonous chemicals were used in the glue. Children would easily get sick in these places and could pass on their disease to others. They were constantly coughing or sneezing on dolls or hats that they made.

In the 1900’s people started to realize that child labor really wasn’t a good thing. Unions had been fighting it since the 1830’s but it took until now to get any true enforcement of child labor laws. In 1842 Massachusetts limited their work day to ten hours, but again it was not in forced. The National Child Labor Committee began its movements in 1904, but it wasn’t until the United States Children’s Bureau, established in 1912, that significant change occurred. With these movements, and photographs of the work places taken by Lewis Hine, Americans began to be concerned with the children’s welfare, and this time the government took action. Congress passed laws in 1916 and 1918 that would apply to the well being of children nationally. But the Supreme Court decided that these laws were unconstitutional since they limited states rights and “denied children the freedom to contract work”. Congress made another attempt to create a national child labor law, but it was struck down due to the issue of federal power.

When the Great Depression hit in the 1930’s, the number of unemployed adults sky-rocketed. At that time, everyone was fighting for any type of job, even the low paying jobs children had. This, along with the extreme work of Unions, child labor began to slowly fade away on its own. Yet in 1938, President Roosevelt made it official when he signed the Fair Labor Standards Act. This created a minimum wage and maximum hours of work for all employees. He also was able to limit child labor to children under the age of sixteen were not allowed to work in manufacturing and mining companies. In 1949 that law was amended to include all businesses such as commercial agriculture, transportation, communications and public utilities.

Even though child labor is illegal in the United States today, it is still used in multiple places around the world. Seventy percent of kids are used for agricultural benefits and about fifteen million are in the manufacturing business. Asia is the main source of child labor, goods such as carpet, clothing, glass, and bricks are all created by children in the poorer classes of Asia. Unions have joined together to create an international movement, but even when child labor is illegal, it still occurs. In the United States less than five percent of children from the ages of five to fourteen are illegally at work, they have been mostly found harvesting fruits and vegetables for commercial agriculture. Yet the definition of work has changed a lot since the 1900’s. Today children thirteen and under are legally allowed to baby sit, mow lawns, deliver newspapers, and other small tasks. It is also legal for children to become professional actors or singers in the United States. Our country has expanded in many ways, we have created regulations to who can work and how much, but out definition and conditions of work have also changed.

Child Labor?

Another topic idea I had was child labor. Heres some history on it that I thought was neat and shocking.

Child labor is the use of young children for work in various places such as factories, mines, sweatshops, and mills. It began as early as 1619 in Colonial America. There was a desperate need for workers among American and British companies, so the use of poor children became popular. America quickly accepted the concept of child labor, since it was less harsh than England. From the beginning spirituality has been a major part of everyday life, and it as believed that idleness was a sin. Therefore having your child work, kept them busy while teaching them responsibility and “building character”. The public wasn’t very informed on the issue of how cruel child labor was; it was only known that their beatings weren’t as harsh as in England. It also made the public happy to know that business owners kept girls out of the coal mines.



The north and south both found a use for child labor. The south always had a place in the tobacco industry, and children by the age of four were able to start working. Later on, children, even really young ones, were used as oyster shuckers. In the south they also tended to use children as black slave replacements in mills and factories. The north also tended to use young children in factories and mills; in fact the textile industry relied greatly on the work of kids. The north also found a use for children, especially boys, as newsboys. Other jobs could be cotton spinners, sweepers, sweatshop workers, breaker boys, construction help, sewing services ect.

Work as a child was not easy. They had long hours; ten to twelve hours a day, including Saturdays. This often was during a school term as well. Various companies actually encouraged parents to take their kids out of school and have them start working, and in some cases parents believed that education was a waste of time to their children. Jon Wild, an employee from the Fall River, Massachusetts mill stated that “when he [a child worker] gets done in the mill, he is ready to go to bed. He has to be in the mill ten minutes before we start up [in the morning], to wind spindles. Then he starts about his own work and keeps till dinner time. Then he goes home, starts again at one, works till seven. When he’s done he’s tired enough to go to bet. Some days he has to clean and help scour during dinner hours [at the mill]…Some days he has to clean spindles. Saturdays he’s in all day.” This is the schedule for a typical mill working child, if they don’t have school to worry about. The thing is without an education most children were illiterate. And since during that time period, spirituality was a big deal, reading the Bible was also very important. It was also a concern that America’s future generation would be illiterate, unless they were upper class. So in 1813 Connecticut passed the first set of laws requiring manufacturers to provide young workers to learn how to read, write and some arithmetic. Though this law was not enforced very well, and with eighty-four hour weeks, there was little time for learning. Yet the idea spread and in 1836 Massachusetts required all workers under the age of fifteen to attend school three months out of the year.

Thursday, February 4, 2010

Research Topic

In AP Language and Composition, we are starting research projects. From what I understand, I have to choose a topic of interest and then find an argument within it that I can research and write an essay about. So at this point, I need to find a topic. I'm considering something in the equine veterinarian area, but I'm not sure what type of argument I could write about. Another idea is researching apologetics.

Apologetics is the art of using logic to defend Christianity. I am currently taking a class in apologetics at my church, and its really interesting. There are many arguments and different ways to discuss different controversy topics using strong evidence, with faith. Now, I know that making a logical argument means I need strong evidence and facts, but when you talk about evolution, you still require a bit of faith, faith in science. Everything we believe requires some faith, and some things require more faith than others. So if I choose this topic, my argument will not only require supportive evidence, but the persuasion that Christianity has more believable reasoning than science.



From writing just that last paragraph I realize that this will be a tough topic to present and write about. I know that I have my own beliefs, but my job wont be to present those, it will be to find out which side of the argument is more logically correct. At this point I'm seeing that there are several sides to the argument; an atheist, a theist, and an pantheist. These are all the world religions put into categories based on how they view God. Atheists view that there is no God, theists view that there is a God and he is apart of everything we do on earth. Pantheists believe that there is a God, but he simply created the earth and left us alone. So in my argument, I would have to present these views, or choose two, and then present the main supporting facts for each.

Another option for my research project, is the argument about what defines a sport. Many people are stuck to the fact that football, baseball, basketball, golf, swimming, volleyball, tennis, and track are only true sports. Thus leaving those such as bowling, figure skating, competitive horse back riding, bike riding, dance, or even marching band, are not true "sports". Well, in my opinion, when an activity requires physical activity, training, or just gives you a workout, it should be considered a sport. All of these activities are competitive and require work, so why do most people laugh when you say that that is your sport?